Dec 1, 2025 · Progressive offers lower rates and stronger satisfaction across most categories than Allstate. Progressive comes out ahead with lower costs and a better digital experience. Allstate's is …

Jan 18, 2024 · Progressive is better than Allstate overall. Allstate and Progressive are comparable when it comes to discounts and insurance options, although Progressive has better consumer reviews and …

Nov 21, 2025 · We discover whether Allstate or Progressive offers cheaper average car insurance rates for you.

In addition to competitive prices, Progressive has multiple discounts and mostly positive customer reviews, although Allstate scores better for its claims process, which we’ll explain more...

Compare Allstate vs. Progressive auto insurance with rates from $39/month for Progressive and $61/month for Allstate. Save more by choosing the right provider.

Dec 20, 2025 · Progressive scores better than Allstate across: Coverage, Financial Strength, Pricing & Discounts, and Claims Satisfaction & Customer Experience. However, Allstate scores better on …

Sep 29, 2025 · Progressive has lower average rates, but Allstate ranks better for customer service in most regions and offers a pay-per-mile program for low-mileage drivers. If you’re in the market for …

Sep 9, 2025 · Progressive offers the cheapest overall auto insurance rates, with average annual premiums of $1,998. Compare this to Allstate, which has average annual rates of $2,509. In this …